Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Is man in his natural state, good or evil?

43 comments:

Lost in Thought said...

Great question Mr. Witman

Unknown said...

Man is evil in his natural state due to sin and if you don't be
I've in sin man is evil due to his fallibility. He is not perfect and thus has the ability to make wicked mistakes.

Grampz0 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

I belive that humans in a natural state are an even blend of good and bad. Insticints and the will of survivial will force men to kill, and generally be "bad". However, human compassion exists, and had existed while in a natural state.

Blending yo'.

Unknown said...

I believe that a man in his natural state can tend to be evil, as in being greedy and jealousy. People will tend to want more and feel that what they have is not enough to satisfy their wants. So over all I believe yes a man in his natural state can be evil.

Unknown said...

I believe that man in his natural state can be both good and bad. It just depends on the person. We can be disrespectful, unkind and so on and so forth but at the same time we can be compassionate and caring. I agree with Cheyenne saying that we are a decent blend of good and evil. Although sometimes we can drift more to the evil side as a whole.

Unknown said...

I believe we all try to be good but there is somewhat of evil in everyone. No one is perfect, no matter how hard we try. Everyone has sinned at least once. So.. Even though it might not be pure evil there is a little in everyone.

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

I think man in his natural state is mostly evil because of greed. Everyone always wants more than what they already have and usually they want what someone else has because of jealousy. But I do believe that a man has the ability to put aside his nature and be kindhearted and unselfish. The problem is that many people don't, so a man in his natural state is still evil.

GageO said...

In the natural state, man is evil because there are no laws or restrictions to govern him. Thus resulting in man sinning.

Unknown said...

Man is evil in a natural state because everyone sins.

Shayley said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Man in his natural state is evil based on the need to survive and the lack of a governing body to enforce law.

Anonymous said...

Man can be good or evil. It depends on what your view of evil or good is. One man could think something is evil and another could think its good. I think it just depends on how people judge what good and evil are.

Anonymous said...

I believe man in his natural state is evil. I think so because without a government people would just kill and hurt others to get what they want. Most people just care about themselves so in my opinion they are evil.

Dax Ruhs said...

Overall man is evil since the begining of time, look at Adam and Eve. Not only does Eve take from the tree but then convences Adam to partake in the sining. I think we are getting worse over time, look at how back in the day we helped each other and now people are all for themselves. I think men strive to be good but its easier to be evil, lets just say most people take the easy rought. DR

Anonymous said...

When we feel threatened, we tend to look after ourselves and think only in terms of survival. So man's natural state is evil because man is selfish.

Chloe Goodwin said...

Man in his natural state want to be good. In his mind he is good.

holton said...

Originally man is good in his natural state. But after the fall the original natural state was altered into the new natural state. This new natural state is evil because of the power of sin in the world. So even babies are born into sin and are natural evil. The only way to break the power of sin in your life is through the power of the Lord Jesus Christ. Only being a born again believer in Jesus Christ can remove the power of sin.

Anonymous said...

I believe that a man in his natural state can be both good and evil. Sometimes a person can do some very mean things and be rude and disrespectful but they can also be kind and loving. It just depends on the person and the situation.

Unknown said...

Man is amoral, he has great potential to do good or evil.

Jordan McCombs said...

A man is evil in his natural state. Without a government to control the people, everyone would do whatever they want and most likely cause harm. But, yet people can be good. It's about who the person is and what situation they're in.

Anonymous said...

Man has had a history of both good and evil and in mans natural state he has the ability to thoses witch path he will take

Anonymous said...

I think it could be good or evil. Everyone has their own opinion of what's good and evil. Someone's good can be another person's thought of being evil.

Anonymous said...

Man in his natural state is evil. Man needs resources to live and with no laws he will do what it takes to get those resources, such as steal and kill.

Unknown said...

Man can be evil in his natural state because its been going for a long time, no one in the world is perfect

Unknown said...

Man can be evil in his natural state because its been going for a long time, no one in the world is perfect

Anonymous said...

Man has a great responsibility, he has a choice to be good or evil.

Anonymous said...

Man is good. The government makes man evil and makes man do stuff he doesn't want to if man was in his natural state there wouldn't be problems

Unknown said...

Man in his natural state is neither good nor evil he simply is. He adjusts his attitude and mind set from neutral according to the situation. So basically Man can go both ways anytime. Ya you like it

Anonymous said...

I believe man is neither, evil or good is all in the reader's opinion. Man will do what it takes to survive and that is to be expected.

Anonymous said...

I believe that a man in his natural state can be both good and evil. Some people can be hateful and rude while other people are kind and thoughtful. Depending on the person depends on wether or not they are good or evil in their natural state.

mayiskies said...

Is mankind evil? We bring arms against our brothers. We often care about money instead of sharing what we have we have this feeling of we earned this it's ours if they want help they should get a job. Ask yourself what are you willing to give up to help people and many of you won't even consider it. Lets go to the first murder of all time Cain killed his brother in cold blood and out of jealousy. Man kind has the desire to survive and will do so at any cost.

tannerjones said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
tannerjones said...

A man in his natural state is good. All a man tries to do is stay alive and this is not evil if he has to kill someone it doesn't become evil until he kills for no reason.

holton said...

Jeff how is man amoral? Money is amoral and we are very different from money are we not?

EllieHouse said...

Man in his natural state has the ability to be good. Man has moments of compassion and generosity. For the most part however, man is evil in a natural state. Man tends to be selfish, envious, and when faced with temptation has a hard time doing the right thing and walking away.

Shayley said...

I think man is good in his natural state. It's the outside influences that change him and make him evil. God made Adam and Eve good, so man started out good it was temptation by the serpent that lead to evil.

Jarod A. Lake said...

Man in his natural state is good in most cases, I believe man naturally wants to be kind to others. It's how one is brought up in the natural state free of government, that decides how kind or if they are even good or evil.

Anonymous said...

I think man in the natural state is really neither good or evil. If there is nothing there to tempt them, they can't really do anything that is "evil" they will only live off of instinct.

Anonymous said...

I believe that everyone has a little evil in them, but there's is also good. Not one is perfect. So that a man in his nature is mostly good but has some evil.

marty e said...

I believe that man, in his natural state is just man, and, in a sense, is neutral to both good and evil. Throughout his life, he is influenced by the good and evil that he sees, hears, and "feels" on a day-to-day basis. How he reacts to these things leads him to either follow one or the other. So, man is neither good nor evil, just adaptable to his surroundings and its influences.

Anonymous said...

I believe man is both, good and evil, depending on how he is treated. If treated poorly he will seek revenge, making you think he is evil. But if treated good and with respect then mad will be happy and be nice making you think he is good. Depends on the situation and how it was handled and how they took it situation makes all the difference.